I've done a good deal of listening these past several days. I reheard at least three disks from Brautigam's Beethoven sonata set. I reheard disk two from volume one of HJ Lim's Beethoven sonata set. I listened to two of Schiff's Beethoven sonata recital/lectures, one opus 7, the other not. All that plus some non Beethovian odds and ends at YouTube including a rather nice Scheherazade.
Of special interest:
. . . "Is there a Mahler Tradition?", Deryck Cooke discusses Mahler's fourth symphony with audio examples drawn mostly from early recordings by those acquainted with the composer as well as Mahler's own piano roll of the work. A 1963 BBC broadcast.
. . . Mahler "Des Knaben Wunderhorn" (Baker/Evans/LPO/Morris). I own this as a Nimbus CD. It is my favorite amongst my several Wunderhorn disks.
Brautigam is the clear winner here, with no great faults and some extremely fine playing in the slow movements and fugue. His less resonant acoustics are a big plus in this sonata in my opinion. Brautigam comes out ahead in Les Adieux too,
I have listened to many pianists' recordings of Hammerklavier- noone can touch Ronald Brautigam, not even close, not even other fortepianists. His is the benchmark!
Ludwig van Beethoven
Den Sie wenn Sie wollten
Doch nicht vergessen sollten
Beethoven's Sonata in F, Opus 54. This little sonata has been very much neglected by pianists and listeners. It's sandwiched in between two giants: the Waldstein and the Appassionata and it is decidedly weird.
There are only two movements and it starts out with a nice, staid tune which resembles the Andante Favori (which Beethoven removed from the Waldstein). After that, it goes completely haywire and the second movement is equally strange, a sort of toccata or perpetuum mobile which is very hard to follow but very entertaining.
I like this sonata a lot- had to listen to it after that..
Ludwig van Beethoven
Den Sie wenn Sie wollten
Doch nicht vergessen sollten
Whilst perusing YouTube for alternate Les Adieux performances I noticed a link to Brautigam. My first reaction was to ignore it, thinking it no more than a posting of the performance available on his SACD set, which I own. But the channel name was not what I remembered from having taken a few SACD upload links. I decided to investigate. It was a good thing I did so.
What we see and hear is a videoed live performance of Les Adieux. I consider Braudigam's disk Adieux one of the set's highlights. I like this even better. To me it's more dynamic and emotive. I still slightly prefer Pollini's videoed live final movement, but Brautigam isn't far behind.
I notice a link for what looks to be the Waldstein from that same recital but have not yet taken it.
You made my day there DP! Not seen this video before.
Ludwig van Beethoven
Den Sie wenn Sie wollten
Doch nicht vergessen sollten
My god she is amazing...the allegretto is full of fire- those deep pounding bass notes in the left hand..wow!! It is so thrilling...sends shivers down my spine...BOOOOOM...
I have never heard it played as good as this by anyone.
Comment