Eroica, funeral march
Is anyone able to tell me if there are different versions of this impressive second movement to B's third symphony?
Lex Kamminga
Lex Kamminga
-
-
Not by Beethoven's hand that's for sure. Are you looking for arrangements of it made for other instruments? My recommendation is that you stick with the original!Originally posted by Lex Kamminga:
Is anyone able to tell me if there are different versions of this impressive second movement to B's third symphony?
Lex Kamminga
------------------
"If I were but of noble birth..." - Rod Corkin
[This message has been edited by Rod (edited 11-19-2001).] -
Mine too !!!Originally posted by Rod:
My recommendation is that you stick with the original!
------------------
ClaudieClaudieComment
-
Yes.. I know what you're talking about... I have the London Festival Orchestra recording, and they play a shortened and mixed up version of the funeral march, very different from what I have in my Dover Score Edition of the symphony
Originally posted by Lex Kamminga:
Is anyone able to tell me if there are different versions of this impressive second movement to B's third symphony?
Lex KammingaComment
-
This mixed up version may have been the result of the recording editor and not some edition of the score! On Classic FM (UK) when they play B's Ode to Joy they always play a drastically edited (shortened) recording and never the complete score. Cheap and nasty for thick people.Originally posted by kfarad:
Yes.. I know what you're talking about... I have the London Festival Orchestra recording, and they play a shortened and mixed up version of the funeral march, very different from what I have in my Dover Score Edition of the symphony
------------------
"If I were but of noble birth..." - Rod CorkinComment
-
That would be very nasty indeed... but I don't think it's the case over here...Originally posted by Rod:
This mixed up version may have been the result of the recording editor and not some edition of the score! On Classic FM (UK) when they play B's Ode to Joy they always play a drastically edited (shortened) recording and never the complete score. Cheap and nasty for thick people.
I've actually heard mention of a shortened version of the Eroica dirge.Comment
Comment