Listening to some of Bach's works for organ. It has been a good and needed experience.
Chris, after listening to some of Bach's organ music written in the minor, to my mind they do have a similar sound to the Toccata and Fugue in D min (BWV 565). What makes me think so even more is the similar sounds works like BWV 578 "The Little", the Prelude to the 1st Cello Suite, and the Fantasia & Fugue BWV 542 have to BWV 565.
Such as if we listen to the Prelude we see Bach is easily capable of writing a similar "catchy" sound to BWV 565. Then take BWV 542 and the depth and heavy and powerful use of minor has a similar "darkness" (I guess could be said) to BWV 565. And BWV 578 has something about it that, to me, has resemblances of BWV 565.
Anyway just some thoughts.
Also, to Sorrano, in regards to your comment in another thread about keeping up with technology - I believe you are right. It, really surprises, me that technology has come so far that there is a YTSO. It almost frightens me, because, technology is such a great power and much of humanity depends on it so greatly for almost everything.
- I hope, or I could not live. - written by H.G. Wells
I have been thinking a little (because I found the saying interesting) about this and the conclusion I came to is it depends of what Beethoven is saying in relation to "difficult". If he means it in a general sense (such as things we do in everyday life - so to say) then I completely disagree. Really, I don't see difficult being a 'good' thing in relation to many things? Though Philip, do you know what it is he was relating "difficult is good" to.
- I hope, or I could not live. - written by H.G. Wells
Difficult, in my experiences has been a good thing. For example, if I learn a difficult piece of music I have grown by exceeding the range of my own comfort zone. I experience new abilities and new sensations.
I have been thinking a little (because I found the saying interesting) about this and the conclusion I came to is it depends of what Beethoven is saying in relation to "difficult". If he means it in a general sense (such as things we do in everyday life - so to say) then I completely disagree. Really, I don't see difficult being a 'good' thing in relation to many things? Though Philip, do you know what it is he was relating "difficult is good" to.
Sorry Preston, I wasn't clear there. I was referring to the BBC "Eroica" film when the actor playing Beethoven says angrily to the actor playing Count Dietrichstein that "Difficult is good". I was asking if it was true that Beethoven actually said that.
Last edited by Quijote; 03-23-2011, 11:11 PM.
Reason: Spelling and clarifications
Caught some of Beethoven's Fourth Piano Concerto on a car journey today. The first movement was fine but - as I expected - I couldn't hear the piano in the second movement until it got near the end.
I have come to the conclusion that many works of Beethoven are not suitable for in-car listening due to his extreme dynamic range (unless you have a super-quiet expensive Merc). Just try to hear the opening of the Ninth symphony without turning up the volume and getting blasted a few moments later.
Bach and Mozart are ideal for car journeys. Anyway, I hate driving.
I couldn't agree with you more! The part about Bach and Mozart being car music not the part about driving!!!
Joy, I agree with myself totally: listening to Michael drives me completely round the bend.
[Add "driving me around the bend" icon; similar to the smiley one, but bendier]
Difficult, in my experiences has been a good thing. For example, if I learn a difficult piece of music I have grown by exceeding the range of my own comfort zone. I experience new abilities and new sensations.
I do agree with you that difficulty can be good - at times. I was approaching it from a completely different perspective. I am thankful for the hardships I have experienced in life - though at the same time, I desperately wish they would end - really it has been enough.
- I hope, or I could not live. - written by H.G. Wells
I do agree with you that difficulty can be good - at times. I was approaching it from a completely different perspective. I am thankful for the hardships I have experienced in life - though at the same time, I desperately wish they would end - really it has been enough.
Just consider, what would Beethoven's music have been like if he had not the hardships he endured?
Comment