There were those critics who felt that Beethoven was extreme (over the top?) in the ranges of passion in his music. In reference, too, to the Heiligenstadt period, remember that the end result of this experience was a spiritual triumph, not a defeat. Beethoven chose to live for his art, to move forward, not backward. While the second symphony is, indeed, one of the sunniest of his works it does begin with some of the darkest moments. This smacks of being autobiographical to me.
In order to understand each composer we have to look at the world around him (her). What were the norms and what was considered extravagant in each's own era? I think that as we do study these things that we do find more than just vague autobiographical references in the music. After all, where does the music come from? It comes from the composers own realm of personal experiences and understandings.
In order to understand each composer we have to look at the world around him (her). What were the norms and what was considered extravagant in each's own era? I think that as we do study these things that we do find more than just vague autobiographical references in the music. After all, where does the music come from? It comes from the composers own realm of personal experiences and understandings.
Comment