Question about Piano Sonatas

[Ludwig Amadeus Schubert]

Right now I'm working on the 'Pathetique' sonata. When I finish it I want to start on the 'Moonlight' or 'Appassionata'. Which one would be better? Maybe it's a stupid question. I know all the sonatas are great but the Appassionata gives me goosebumps when I listen to the ALLEGRO MA NON TROPPO, I don't know =\.

[Chris]

The "Appassionata" is quite a bit more difficult than the "Pathetique," so be prepared. The 3rd movement of the "Moonlight" is also quite difficult. I personally would not suggest either one to follow the "Pathetique," but if you must do one of those two, I'd go with the "Moonlight."

[Claudie MICAULT]

Try opus 10 n° 3...

Claudie

------------------
Claudie

[Rutradelusasa]

The first sonata I did of B. was the 14th, if you are on the 8th (wich I consider more difficult than the 14th) I suggest you to chosse between 12th, 14th or 15th.
The whole "14th Sonata is VERY difficult" is a myt, don't get intimidated by that.

[Vipercat]

Hi Chris,

Why do you not recommend either "Moonlight" or "Appasionata" to follow the Pathetique? Is there any specific reason besides difficulty?

Interested,
Vipercat

[Chris]

That's pretty much it. There is a HUGE difference in difficulty between the two.

[Franz_Liszt]

I love the "Appassionata" so much. It is the reason I began piano, and I am currently studying the piece. I am complete with the third movement, I wanted to begin with the most difficult movement. It is much more difficult than Pathetique, so I advise you to really consider "Appassionata." I work very hard, and if you are willing to devote countless hours for "Appassionata," go for it. I would choose it over "Moonlight" Sonata. You must listen to other Beethoven Sonatas, they are some great ones. I still prefer "Appassionata." Like you, it just touches me in that special way. I am also working on "Les Adieux." You might consider Op. 10 No. 3 in D Major or Op. 109 in E Major. I hope this reply helps you in some manner. If you have anymore questions, feel free to ask!