10 th symphony mp3 request

[Mustafa Umut Sarac]

Hello , This is my first post to the list and I want to present my best.
I want to listen Beethoven 10th Symphıony.
Can anyone send the mp3 set ?
It is totally legal.
my e mail : mustafaumutsarac@gmail.com

Kind regards ,

Mustafa Umut Sarac

[susanwen]

If anyone is sending, you might as well send it to the whole list, and let us all enjoy it : }

[Cetto von Cronstorff]

Hello , This is my first post to the list and I want to present my best.
I want to listen Beethoven 10th Symphıony.
Can anyone send the mp3 set ?
It is totally legal.
my e mail : mustafaumutsarac@gmail.com

'Beethoven's 10th' is not by Beethoven, but a concoction perpetrated by Barry Cooper. Don't be mistaken about this.

[Peter]

'Beethoven's 10th' is not by Beethoven, but a concoction perpetrated by Barry Cooper. Don't be mistaken about this.

Absolutely - how this can be palmed off as Beethoven's 10th is astounding.

[Hofrat]

Barry Cooper never "palmed" it off as Beethoven. I have a copy of Cooper's manuscript where he wrote "realized and completed by Barry Cooper."

[Peter]

Barry Cooper never "palmed" it off as Beethoven. I have a copy of Cooper's manuscript where he wrote "realized and completed by Barry Cooper."

I never said he did - I was referring to commentators and marketing.

[Cetto von Cronstorff]

Barry Cooper never "palmed" it off as Beethoven. I have a copy of Cooper's manuscript where he wrote "realized and completed by Barry Cooper."

You forgot to quote the preceding main title on the CD as well which reads in bold script:

'Beethoven's 10th Symphony'.

[Hofrat]

Dear Cetto;

I have a master recording of it done in France in 2002. Here the piece was called: "Symphony 10, first movement, Biamonti 838, realization by Barry Cooper."

[Hofrat]

Also on this master recording are the following:

Symphony movement in C-minor, Hess 298.
Adagio in E for a symphony.
Minuet in D-minor from the Fischof Miscellany.
Concerto movement in C for violin and orchestra, Woo 5.
Oboe concerto movement, Hess 12.
Overture to Macbeth, Biamonti 454.

If this recording would have been released, it would have easily been discerned that all the works were realizations. It is such a shame that these remarkable pieces will not be heard anytime soon.

[Peter]

Also on this master recording are the following:

Symphony movement in C-minor, Hess 298.
Adagio in E for a symphony.
Minuet in D-minor from the Fischof Miscellany.
Concerto movement in C for violin and orchestra, Woo 5.
Oboe concerto movement, Hess 12.
Overture to Macbeth, Biamonti 454.

If this recording would have been released, it would have easily been discerned that all the works were realizations. It is such a shame that these remarkable pieces will not be heard anytime soon.

But these are not 'Beethoven works', only completed fragments or sketches. We know from Beethoven's methods that he would refine ideas for years - he even revised his own completed works after they had been performed - the 2nd piano concerto, the 1st string quartet and the Eroica are some examples.

[Hofrat]

Well, let us scrap Mozart's "Requiem" (completed by Sussmayer) and Puccini's "Turandot" (completed by Alfano) too.

[Peter]

Well, let us scrap Mozart's "Requiem" (completed by Sussmayer) and Puccini's "Turandot" (completed by Alfano) too.

That's a silly argument Hofrat as those works were far more substantially completed. There is no such thing as Beethoven's 'Macbeth overture' - a few sketches which were later incorporated into the ghost trio do not amount to the same thing at all.