Originally posted by Gurn
atserri,
You are a braver person that I am! ALthough I must say, you make it sound intriguing. I shall keep my eyes open for that disk.
atserri,
You are a braver person that I am! ALthough I must say, you make it sound intriguing. I shall keep my eyes open for that disk.
I am curious about this! Would you consider the music to be more Eastern than Western and would you consider it to be more 20th Century than 19th? Sounds intriguing!
The Hashimoto music is very nice, nevertheless the symphony was composed for the 2600th anniversary of Japan so it is (as was ehem... REQUESTED) positive, nationalistic and plain to satisfy a wide audience keeping the grandeur. Once said that, perhaps a little discouraging, the 3rd. movement is for me the more interesting (the first exposes the evolution and history of japan, so the music alternates fights with piece and its last part a little occidentalization, and the 2nd movement consists on traditonal japanese songs from different provinces tied and linked, curious but as said, quite plain). Third movement is a theme (almost a second national anthem is said) and 8 variation, there the use of traditional instruments in more western structures and a composition closer to western, is more interesting. The other piece is more interesting (Heavenly maid and the fisherman) a orchestral ballet very influenced by western ballet, perhaps is a superior piece musically despite was composed 6 years before the symphony, because he had any limitation and was suposed to be more "western".
Yamada: I found him very original and his music more "risky" in terms of occidentalization, the symphony is very emotional since tries to put together the need of peace and the joy of victory in a war. It's certainly a deeper piece, with more profound orchestration (even though has some "military" parts quite simple), and surpisingly, the beginning of the first movement derives from the japanese anthem itself, which I think that in the beginning of 20th century in japan would be shocking.
I haven't listened to his symphonic poems but they look very promising and emotional.
I'll need some help in defining the music more 19th century-ish ot 20th century-ish.
Comment